马烨,刘于思

• 1:四川大学文学与新闻学院
• 2:南京大学新闻学院

摘要(Abstract)：

当代新闻业研究中，话语制度主义因其对话语权力和制度动态变迁的关注，逐渐成为一种重要的理论工具。但随着这一视角的广泛应用，理论误用的现象也逐渐显现。本研究聚焦于话语制度主义视角的理论吸引力及其在新闻业研究中独特的解释优势与局限性，对近年来国内外新闻业研究中话语制度主义的运用情况展开批判性分析。在未能充分考虑时空背景、制度层次和动态协商机制的情况下，将话语制度主义误用为新闻业研究单一解释框架，可能导致进入理论误区。本研究通过澄清话语制度主义的理论前提及其为新闻业研究带来的相应参考定位，呼吁对话语制度主义进行更加审慎的使用，为该理论本土化应用提供了规范化建议。

关键词(KeyWords)： 话语制度主义;新闻业;观念;新闻制度;新闻实践

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 国家社科基金青年项目“近现代新闻话语中‘天下观’的演进与文明互鉴研究”(项目批准号:25CXW005)的研究成果

作者(Author): 马烨,刘于思

参考文献(References)：

• 简丹丹、白红义(2024):话语制度主义视角下的数字新闻业，《新闻春秋》,第5期，3-11页。
• 毛天婵(2023):谁是经营者：话语制度主义视野下传媒经营者的职业角色，《新闻爱好者》,第7期，86-88页。
• 施好音、白红义(2024):新闻业怀旧中的“话语制度”——基于电影《不止不休》的案例研究，《新闻记者》,第4期，46-63页。
• 虞鑫(2019):话语制度主义：地方政府回应公众意见的理论解释——基于“意见-政策”连接理论的多案例比较分析，《新闻与传播研究》,第26卷第5期，21-40,126页。
• 周睿鸣(2019):“转型”:观念的形成、元话语重构与新闻业变迁——对“澎湃新闻”的案例研究，《国际新闻界》,第41卷第3期，55-72页。
• Alasuutari,P.(2015).The discursive side of new institutionalism.Cultural Sociology,9(2),162-184.doi:10.1177/1749975514561805.
• Banjac,S.(2022).Audiences as a discursive institution?How audience expectations disrupt the journalistic field.In Ferrucci,P.& Eldridge,S.A.II (Eds.),The Institutions Changing Journalism:Barbarians Inside the Gate (pp.75-88).London:Routledge.
• Bourdieu,P.(2005).The political field,the social science field,and the journalistic field.In Benson,R.& Neveu,E.(Eds.),Bourdieu and the Journalistic Field (pp.29-47).Cambridge:Polity Press.
• Canter,L.(2015).Personalised tweeting:The emerging practices of journalists on Twitter.Digital Journalism,3(6),888-907.doi:10.1080/21670811.2014.973148.
• Carlson,M.(2016).Metajournalistic discourse and the meanings of journalism:Definitional control,boundary work,and legitimation.Communication Theory,26(4),349-368.doi:10.1111/comt.12088.
• Carstensen,M.B.& Schmidt,V.A.(2016).Power through,over and in ideas:Conceptualizing ideational power in discursive institutionalism.Journal of European Public Policy,23(3),318-337.doi:10.1080/13501763.2015.1115534.
• Chadwick,A.(2013).The hybrid media system:Politics and power.Oxford:Oxford University Press.doi:10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199759477.001.0001.
• Cook,T.E.(1998).Governing with the news:The news media as a political institution.Chicago,IL:University of Chicago Press.
• Culpepper,P.D.(2008).The politics of common knowledge:Ideas and institutional change in wage bargaining.International Organization,62(1),1-33.doi:10.1017/S0020818308080016.
• Dryzek,J.S.(2000).Deliberative democracy and beyond.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
• Eldridge,S.A.(2022).Introduction:Journalism coming into being:The timbers and planks of a changing institution.In Ferrucci,P.& Eldridge,S.A.II (Eds.),The Institutions Changing Journalism:Barbarians Inside the Gate (pp.1-14).London:Routledge.
• Ferrucci,P.& Vos,T.(2017).Who's in,who's out?Constructing the identity of digital journalists.Digital Journalism,5(7),868-883.doi:10.1080/21670811.2016.1208054.
• Ferrucci,P.,Taylor,R.& Alaimo,K.I.(2020).On the boundaries:Professional photojournalists navigating identity in an age of technological democratization.Digital Journalism,8(3),367-385.doi:10.1080/21670811.2020.1732830.
• Ferrucci,P.(2022).Conclusion:Understanding the institutions influencing journalism:Ideas for future work.In Ferrucci,P.& Eldridge,S.A.II (Eds.),The Institutions Changing Journalism:Barbarians Inside the Gate (pp.180-192).London:Routledge.
• Foucault,M.(2000).Power.Volume 3:Essential works of Foucault,1954—1984.New York:New Press.
• Freedman,D.(2008).The politics of media policy.Cambridge,UK:Polity.
• Ganter,S.A.& L??blich,M.(2021).Discursive media institutionalism:Assessing Vivien A.Schmidt's framework and its value for media and communication studies.International Journal of Communication,15,2281-2300.
• Haas,P.M.(1992).Introduction:Epistemic communities and international policy coordination.International organization,46(1),1-35.doi:10.1017/S0020818300001442.
• Habermas,J.(1989).The structural transformation of the public sphere (T.Burger,Trans.) Cambridge,MA:The MIT Press.
• Hajer,M.A.(1993).Discourse coalitions and the institutionalization of practice:The case of acid rain in Great Britain.In Fischer,F.& Forester,J.(Eds.),The Argumentative Turn in Policy Analysis and Planning (pp.43-76).Durham,NC:Duke University Press.doi:10.1215/9780822381815-003.
• Hall,P.A.& Taylor,R.C.R.(1996).Political science and the three new institutionalisms.Political Studies,44(5),936-957.doi:10.1111/j.1467-9248.1996.tb00343.x.
• Hanitzsch,T.(2007).Deconstructing journalism culture:Toward a universal theory.Communication Theory,17(4),367-385.doi:10.1111/j.1468-2885.2007.00303.x.
• Hanitzsch,T.& Vos,T.P.(2017).Journalistic roles and the struggle over institutional identity:The discursive constitution of journalism.Communication Theory,27(2),115-135.doi:10.1111/comt.12112.
• Hanitzsch,T.& Vos,T.P.(2018).Journalism beyond democracy:A new look into journalistic roles in political and everyday life.Journalism,19(2),146-164.doi:10.1177/1464884916673386.
• Hanusch,F.& Tandoc,E.C.,Jr.(2019).Comments,analytics,and social media:The impact of audience feedback on journalists' market orientation.Journalism,20(6),695-713.doi:10.1177/1464884916673386.
• Hedman,U.(2020).Making the most of Twitter:How technological affordances influence Swedish journalists' self-branding.Journalism,21(5),670-687.doi:10.1177/1464884917734054.
• Henriksen,T.D.(2008).Liquidating roles and crystallising positions:Investigating the road between role and positioning theory.In Moghaddam,F.M.,Harré,R.& Lee,N.(Eds.),Global Conflict Resolution Through Positioning Analysis (pp.41-64).New York,NY:Springer.doi:10.1007/978-0-387-72112-5_3.
• Huntington,S.P.(1968).Political order in changing societies.New Haven,CT:Yale University Press.
• J??ger,S.& Maier,F.(2016).Analysing discourses and dispositives:A Foucauldian approach to theory and methodology.In Wodak,R.& Meyer,M.(Eds.),Methods of Critical Discourse Studies (3rd ed.,pp.109-136).London:SAGE.
• Koliska,M.,Chadha,K.& Burns,A.(2020).Talking back:Journalists defending attacks against their profession in the Trump era.Journalism Studies,21(11),1496-1513.doi:10.1080/1461670X.2020.1763190.
• Koliska,M.& Assmann,K.(2021).Lügenpresse:The lying press and German journalists' responses to a stigma.Journalism,22(11),2729-2746.doi:10.1177/1464884919894088.
• Koliska,M.& Chadha,K.(2023).Taking a stand:The discursive re-positioning of journalism.Journalism Studies,24(4),442-459.doi:10.1080/1461670X.2023.2167107.
• Laclau,E.& Mouffe,C.(1985).Hegemony and socialist strategy:Towards a radical democratic politics.London:Verso.
• Lewis,S.C.,Guzman,A.L.,Schmidt,T.R.& Lin,B.B.(2025).Generative AI and its disruptive challenge to journalism:An institutional analysis.Communication and Change,1(1),9.doi:10.1007/S44382-025-00008-X.
• Lukes,S.(1974).Power:A radical view.London:MacMillan.
• Makhashvili,A.,Medeiros,D.& Lünenborg,M.(2022).Challenging journalistic authority in the networked affective dynamics of #Chemnitz.Social Media+Society,8(4),1-14.20563051221146185.doi:10.1177/20563051221146185.
• Merton,R.K.(1957).The role-set:Problems in sociological theory.The British Journal of Sociology,8(2),106-120.doi:10.2307/587363.
• Meyer,J.W.& Jepperson,R.L.(2000).The “actors” of modern society:The cultural construction of social agency.Sociological Theory,18(1),100-120.doi:10.1111/0735-2751.00090.
• Molyneux,L.(2015).What journalists retweet:Opinion,humor,and brand development on Twitter.Journalism,16(7),920-935.doi:10.1177/1464884914550135.
• Neff,T.& Pickard,V.(2023).Building better local media systems:A comparative policy discourse analysis of initiatives to renew journalism around the world.Journalism Studies,24(15),1877-1897.doi:10.1080/1461670X.2023.2253928.
• Ostrom,E.(1990).Governing the commons:The evolution of institutions for collective action.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
• Parsons,C.(2007).How to map arguments in political science.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
• Parsons,T.(1951).The social system.London:Routledge & Kegan Paul.
• Peters,B.G.(2019).Institutional theory in political science:The new institutionalism (4th ed.).Cheltenham:Edward Elgar Publishing.
• Phillips,N.,Lawrence,T.B.& Hardy,C.(2004).Discourse and institutions.The Academy of Management Review,29(4),635-652.doi:10.2307/20159075.
• Pinch,T.(2008).Technology and institutions:Living in a material world.Theory and Society,37(5),461-483.doi:10.1007/s11186-008-9069-x.
• Puppis,M.,Mansell,R.& Van den Bulck,H.(2024).Introduction to media and communication governance:From labelling to theorizing and practice.In Handbook of Media and Communication Governance (pp.1-26).Cheltenham:Edward Elgar Publishing.
• Raemy,P.(2021).A theory of professional identity in journalism:Connecting discursive institutionalism,socialization,and psychological resilience theory.Communication Theory,31(4),841-861.doi:10.1093/ct/qtaa019.
• Raemy,P.& Vos,T.P.(2021).A negotiative theory of journalistic roles.Communication Theory,31(1),107-126.doi:10.1093/ct/qtaa030.
• Rantanen,T.& Kelly,A.(2020).Abnegation,accommodation and affirmation:Three discursive modes for the institutional construction of independence among national news agency executives in Europe.Journalism,21(12),1896-1912.doi:10.1177/1464884919880060.
• Reese,S.D.(2022).The institution of journalism:Conceptualizing the press in a hybrid media system.Digital Journalism,10(2),253-266.doi:10.1080/21670811.2021.1977669.
• Russell,F.M.(2019).The new gatekeepers:An institutional-level view of Silicon Valley and the disruption of journalism.Journalism Studies,20(5),631-648.doi:10.1080/1461670X.2017.1412806.
• Schmidt,V.A.(2008).Discursive institutionalism:The explanatory power of ideas and discourse.Annual Review of Political Science,11(1),303-326.doi:10.1146/annurev.polisci.11.060606.135342.
• Schmidt,V.A.(2010).Taking ideas and discourse seriously:Explaining change through discursive institutionalism as the fourth ‘new institutionalism’.European Political Science Review,2(1),1-25.doi:10.1017/S175577390999021X.
• Schmidt,V.A.(2012).Discursive institutionalism:Scope,dynamics,and philosophical underpinnings.In Fischer,F.& Gottweis,H.(Eds.),The Argumentative Turn Revisited:Public Policy as Communicative Practice (pp.85-113).Durham,NC:Duke University Press.doi:10.1215/9780822395362-004.
• Schmidt,V.A.(2015).Discursive institutionalism:Understanding policy in context.In Fischer,F.,Torgerson,D.,Durnová,A.& Orsini,M.(Eds.),Handbook of Critical Policy Studies (pp.171-189).Cheltenham:Edward Elgar Publishing.doi:10.4337/9781783472352.00016.
• Schmidt,V.A.(2016).The roots of neo-liberal resilience:Explaining continuity and change in background ideas in Europe's political economy.The British Journal of Politics and International Relations,18(2),318-334.doi:10.1177/1369148115612792.
• Sparrow,B.H.(2006).A research agenda for an institutional media.Political Communication,23(2),145-157.doi:10.1080/10584600600629695.
• Standaert,O.,Hanitzsch,T.& Dedonder,J.(2021).In their own words:A normative-empirical approach to journalistic roles around the world.Journalism,22(4),919-936.doi:10.1177/1464884919853183.
• Sybert,J.(2024).Difficult memories as institutional narrative:U.S.journalists' recollections of 9/11 across three anniversaries.Journalism Studies,25(8),837-855.doi:10.1080/1461670X.2024.2342420.
• Van Dalen,A.(2019).Journalism,trust,and credibility.In Wahl-Jorgensen,K.& Hanitzsch,T.(Eds.),The Handbook of Journalism Studies (2nd ed.,pp.356-371).New York:Routledge.
• Van Dijk,T.A.(1993).Principles of critical discourse analysis.Discourse & Society,4(2),249-283.doi:10.1177/0957926593004002006.
• Vos,T.P.(2016).Historical perspectives on journalistic roles.In Mellado,C.,Hellmueller,L.& Donsbach,W.(Eds.),Journalistic Role Performance (pp.59-77).New York:Routledge.
• Vos,T.(2019,February 25).Journalism as Institution.Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Communication.Retrieved from https://oxfordre.com/commu nication/view/10.1093/acrefore/9780190228613.001.0001/acrefore-97801902286 13-e-825.
• Vos,T.P.& Perreault,G.P.(2020).The discursive construction of the gamification of journalism.Convergence,26(3),470-485.doi:10.1177/1354856520909542.
• Vos,T.P.,Thomas,R.J.& Tandoc,E.C.,Jr.(2023).Constructing the legitimacy of journalists' marketing role.Journalism Studies,24(6),763-782.doi:10.1080/1461670X.2023.2187650.
• Wang,Q.(2020).Differentiation and de-differentiation:The evolving power dynamics between news industry and tech industry.Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly,97(2),509-527.doi:10.1177/1077699020916809.
• Widmaier,W.W.,Blyth,M.& Seabrooke,L.(2007).Exogenous shocks or endogenous constructions?The meanings of wars and crises.International Studies Quarterly,51(4),747-759.doi:10.1111/j.1468-2478.2007.00474.x.
• Wodak,R.(2001).What CDA is about—A summary of its history,important concepts and its developments.In Wodak,R.and Meyer,M.(Eds.),Methods of Critical Discourse Analysis (pp.1-22).London:SAGE.doi:10.4135/9780857028020.n1.
• Wodak,R.(2009).The discourse of politics in action.London:Palgrave Macmillan.doi:10.1057/9780230316539.
• Wueest,B.& Fossati,F.(2015).Quantitative discursive institutionalism:A comparison of labour market policy discourse across Western Europe.Journal of European Public Policy,22(5),708-730.doi:10.1080/13501763.2014.976834.
• Zaller,J.R.(1992).The nature and origins of mass opinion.New York:Cambridge University Press.