Azmet Rasul,Stephen D.McDowell,邹胜

• 1:佛罗里达州立大学传播学院
• 2:清华大学新闻与传播学院

摘要(Abstract)：

巴基斯坦政界认为该国电子媒体管理局催生了国内媒介产业的前所未有的演变,促使传媒所有权日渐集中化,并使得传媒机构所有者享受不受约束的政治影响力。事实上,历届巴基斯坦政府都试图重新审视其以往在媒体管制和电子媒体执照批准方面的政策,过去效率低下的电子媒体管理局受政府指示,重新考虑一些有关跨媒体所有权和新办电视频道批准程序的政策举措。本文将从传媒政治经济学的视角探究巴基斯坦媒体管制和传媒所有权集中化之间的关系,并得出结论,即巴基斯坦电子媒介管理部门因其利于媒体所有者的政策及其低下的效率和执行力,导致传媒所有权的集中化,从而推动几家大公司进行交叉扩张,控制了该国传媒产业的命脉。

关键词(KeyWords)： 管制;所有权集中化;政治经济学;巴基斯坦电子媒体管理局;媒介产业

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation):

作者(Author): Azmet Rasul,Stephen D.McDowell,邹胜

DOI: 10.16602/j.gmj.2014.01.006

参考文献(References)：

• Ahmed,Z,S.&Stephan,M.J.(2010).Fighting for the rule of law:Civilresistance and the lawyers’movement in Pakistan.Democratization,17(3),492-513.
• Ali,O.A.&Gunaratne,S.A.(2000).Pakistan.In S.A.Gunaratne(Ed.),Handbook of the Media in South Asia(pp.155-181).New Delhi:Sage.
• Anderson,C.W.(1992).The Place of Principles in Policy Analysis.In J.M.Gillroy&M.Wade(Eds.),The Moral Dimension of Public Policy Choice:Beyond the Market Paradigm(pp.387-409).Pittsburgh:University ofPittsburgh Press.
• Aufderheide,P.(2007).Communication Policy and the Public Interest.In D.Graber(Ed.),Media Power in Politics(pp.364-375).Washington D.C:CQPress.
• Bagdikian,B.(2004).The New Media Monopoly.Boston:Beacon Press.
• Baker,C.E.(2007).Media Concentration and Democracy:Why Ownership Matters.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
• Behuria,A.K.(2009).How Military Dominates the Political Space in Pakistan:AStudy of Musharraf’s Rule(1999—2008).Journal of Peace Studies,16(1-2),76-102.
• Bernstein,M.(1955).Regulatory Business by Independent Commissions.Princeton:Princeton University Press.
• Bhatti,A.A.(2010,December,29).PEMRA and Electronic Media Reforms inPakistan.The News International.p.3.
• Castells,M.(2004).The Information Age:Economy,Society,and Culture.New Jersey:Wiley-Blackwell.
• Chalaby,J.(2005).From Internationalization to Transnationalization.Global Media and Communication,1(1),28-32.
• Cheema,U.(2011).Challenges to the Freedom of Press in Pakistan.Lahore:Punjab University Press.
• Chomsky,N.(1989).Necessary Illusions:Thought Control in Democratic Societies.London:Pluto Press.
• Croteau,D.&Hoynes,W.(2006).The Business of Media:Corporate Media andthe Public Interest.Thousand Oaks,CA:Pine Gorge Press.
• Dar,N.(2008,October 25).Information Revolution in Pakistan.The Nation,16.
• Doyle,G.(2002).Media Ownership:The Economics and Politics of Convergenceand Concentration in the U.K.and European Media.London:Sage.
• Gallup Pakistan.(2010).Gallup Pakistan’s Annual Advertising Expenditure Data.Retrieved from http://www.gallup.com.pk/GallupPakistanAdSpend.php.
• Gunaratne,S.A.(1999).The media in Asia:An overview.InternationalCommunicationGazette,61(3),197-223.
• Hassan,M.(2002).Journalism for All.Lahore:Fazal Publishers.
• Hesmondhalgh,D.(2007).The Cultural Industries.London:Sage.
• Hijazi,M.A.(1996).Mass Communication:Theory and Practice.Lahore:AOne Publishers.
• Horowitz,R.B.(1989).The Irony of Regulatory Reform:The Deregulation of American Telecommunications.New York:Oxford University Press.
• Husband,C.(2005).Minority Ethnic Media as Communities of Practice:Professionalism and Identity Politics in Interaction.Journal of Ethnic andMigration Studies,31(3),461-479.
• Iyer,V.(Ed.)(1999).Media Regulation for the New Times.Singapore:Asian Media Information and Communication Centre(AMIC).
• Jabbar,J.(1999).Regulation of the“New Media”:The Pakistani Experience.InV.Iyer(Ed.),Media Regulation for the New Times,140-147.Singapore:Asian Media Information and Communication Centre(AMIC).
• Jabbar,J.(2003,September 19).Community-based Radio and TV.Dawn,5.
• Jabbar,J.(2011,July 25).New Face of Electronic Media.Pakistan Today,12.
• Javed,M.M.(2002).Regulation,Competition,and Information.The Pakistan Development Review,41(4),911-913.
• Jensen,R.(1998).First Amendment Potluck.Communication Law and Policy,4(3),563-588.
• Joseph,A.(2009,June 20).Broadcast Regulation in the Public Interest:A Backgrounder[Online].Info Change India.Retrieved from http://infochangeindia.org/Media/Broadcast-Laws-and-Regulations/Broadcast-regulation-in-the-publicinterest-A-backgrounder.html.
• Kemal,A.R.(2002).Regulatory Framework in Pakistan.The Pakistan Development Review,41(4),319-332.
• Khan,R.Q.(2008,June 30).Development of Electronic Media in Pakistan.ThePost,A6.
• Klaehn,J.(Ed.)(2010).The Political Economy of Media and Power.NewYork:Peter Lang Publishing.
• Kumar,K.J.(1995).Media Education,Communications,and Public Policy:An Indian Perspective.Mumbai:Himalaya Publishing House.
• Kumar,K.J.&Thomas,A.O.(2006).Telecommunications and Development:The Cellular Mobile“Revolution”in India and China.Journal of CreativeCommunications,3(1),297-309.
• Kunczik,M.(1997).Media Giants:Ownership Concentration and Globalization.Bonn:Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung(FES).
• Laffont,J.J.&Tirole,J.(1993).A Theory of Incentives in Regulation and Procurement.Cambridge:MIT Press.
• LeDuc,D.R.(1988).The Plight of the“Public Interest”:A Principle Lost in theProcess.Journal of Media Law&Practice,4,130-143.
• Lewis,J.(2010).The Myth of Commercialism:Why a Marketing Approach toBroadcasting Does not Work?In J.Klaehn(Ed.),The Political Economy ofMedia and Power,337-356.New York:Peter Lang Publishing.
• Ludes,P.(2008).Convergence and Fragmentation.Chicago:Intellect Books.
• Lunt,P.&Livingstone,S.(2012).Media Regulation:Governance and theInterest of Citizens and Consumers.London:Sage.
• Mc Chesney,R.W.(1999).Rich Media,Poor Democracy:CommunicationPolitics in Dubious Times.New York:The New Press.
• Mc Chesney,R.W.(2004).The Problem of the Media:U.S.Communication Politics in the 21st Century.New York:Monthly Review Press.
• Mc Chesney,R.W.(2008).The Political Economy of Media:Enduring Issues,Emerging Dilemmas.New York:Monthly Review press.
• Mc Dowell,S.D.(1997).Globalization and Policy Choice:Television andAudiovisual Services Policies in India.Media Culture&Society,19(2),151-172.
• McDowell,S.(2001).The Unsovereign Century:Canada’s Media Industries and Cultural Policies.In N.Morris&S.Waisbord(Eds.),Media andGlobalization:Why the State Matters,117-132.New York:Rowman&Littlefield.
• Methu,Z.A.(2012).Growth of English Language Media in Pakistan.Journal of South Asian Studies,22(1),36-55.
• Mir,H.(2001,November 10).Osama Claims He Has Nukes:If US Uses N-armsIt Will Get Same Response.Dawn.Retrieved from http://archives.dawn.com/2001/11/10/top1.htm.
• Morley,D.(2000).Home Territories:Media,Mobility and Identity.London:Sage.
• Mosco,V.(2008).Current Trends in the Political Economy of Communication.Global Media Journal--Canadian Edition,1(1),45-63.
• Mosco,V.(2009).The Political Economy of Communication.London:Sage.
• Napoli,P.M.(1997).A Principal-agent Approach to the Study of Media Organizations:Toward a Theory of the Media Firm.Political Communication,14(2),207-219.
• Napoli,P.M.(2003).Foundations of Communication Policy:Principles and Processes in Regulation of Electronic Media.Cresskill,NJ:Hampton Press.
• Napoli,P.M.(2011).Audience Evolution:New Technologies and the Transformation of Media Audiences.New York:Columbia University Press.
• Naseer,S.(2010).Regulation of Electronic Media and Democracy in Pakistan.Journal of Political Studies,17(2),27-45.
• Old mogul,new media.(2006,January 19).The Economist.Retrieved fromhttp://www.economist.com.
• Olson,M.(1982).The Rise and Decline of Nations:Economic Growth,Stagflation and Social Rigidities.New Haven:Yale University Press.
• Owen,B.M.(1978).The Economic View of Programming.Journal of Communication,28(2),43-50.
• Oxley,M.G.(1993).The Cable-telco Cross-ownership Prohibition:First Amendment Infringement through Obsolescence.Federal Communication LawJournal,7-37,46.
• PEMRA.(2012).Functions.Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authority(PEMRA).Retrieved from http://www.pemra.gov.pk/pemra/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=2&Itemid=4.
• PEMRA.(2012).Government of Pakistan.Ministry of Information and Broadcasting Notification.Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authority(PEMRA).Retrieved from http://www.pemra.gov.pk/pemra/images/docs/legislation/PEMRA_Rules_2009.pdf.
• Rantanen,T.(2007).Flows and Contra-flows in Transitional Societies.In D.K.Thussu(Ed.),Media on the Move:Global Flow and Contra-Flow(pp.165-181).New York:Routledge.
• Rasul,A.(2004).Role of Radio in Development:The Case of Pakistan.Journalof Mass Communication,11(2),54-67.
• Rasul,A.&Proffitt,J.M.(2011).Bollywood and the Indian Premier League(IPL):The Political Economy of Bollywood’s New Blockbuster.Asian Journalof Communication,21(4),373-388.
• Rasul,A.&McDowell,S.D.(2011,June).Regulation and Media Monopoly:ACase Study of Broadcast Regulation in Pakistan.In Y.Chou(Chair),Telecommunications Policy-Asian Perspectives.Paper presented at theInternational Telecommunication Society Asia-Pacific Regional Conference,Taipei,Taiwan.
• Robison,K.K.&Crenshaw,E.M.(2002).Post-industrial Transformations andCyber-space:A Cross-national Analysis of Internet Development.SocialScience Research,31,334-363.
• Sabir,M.(2009).Development of Media Organizations and Social Change in Pakistan.Lahore:Punjab University Press.
• Smythe,D.(1978).Rejoinder to Graham Murdock.Canadian Journal of Political and Social Theory,2(2),120-127.
• Stigler,G.(1971).The Theory of Economic Regulation.Bell Journal of Economics,2,3-21.
• Tahir,S.N.(1996).Television in Pakistan:An Overview.In D.French and M.Richards(Eds.),Contemporary Television:Eastern Perspectives,113-131.New Delhi:Sage.
• Thussu,D.K.(1999).Privatizing the Airwaves:The Impact of Globalization on Broadcasting in India.Media,Culture&Society,21(1),125-131.
• Thussu,D.K.(2007).The“Murdochization”of News?The Case of Star TV inIndia.Media,Culture&Society,29(4),593-611.
• Wasko,J.(1994).Hollywood in the Information Age:Beyond the Silver Screen.London:Polity Press.
• Wasko,J.(2004).Show Me the Money:Challenging Hollywood Economics.In A.Calabrese&C.Sparks(Eds.).Towards a Political Economy of Culture:Capitalism and Communication in the Twenty-first Century(pp.131-151).Boulder,CO:Rowman&Littlefield.
• Werbach,K.(1997).The Digital Tornado:The Internet and Telecommunications Policy.Federal Communication Commission,Office of Plans and PolicyWorking Paper#29.Washington,D.C:Federal Communication Commission.
• Zeitlin,A.(1999,February 23).Movement Afoot to Ease Government Control of Broadcast Media in Pakistan[Online].The Freedom Forum.Retrieved fromhttp://www.freedomforum.org/international/1999/2/23pakistan.asp.
• Zoonen,V.L.(2005).Entertaining the Citizen.Oxford:Rowman&Little fieldPublishers.