闫文捷,刘于思,周睿鸣

• 1:北京师范大学新闻传播学院
• 2:浙江大学传媒与国际文化学院

摘要(Abstract)：

近年来，事实核查这一新型新闻样式正得到新闻从业者社群内外的共同青睐。从“核查什么”到“谁来核查”,事实核查的行动者日益多元。本文由此指出事实核查当前面临的边界协商，并认为其核心问题是数字化新闻变迁中的元新闻话语重塑。参与式事实核查的规范性愿景在于确立新闻活动的认知权威，使核查发掘的事实性信息和抵近的真相构成公众共同的社会知识，奠定开展公共讨论、塑造共识、影响公共政策的基础。

关键词(KeyWords)： 参与式事实核查;边界协商;元新闻话语;认知权威

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 北京市社会科学基金重点项目“社交媒体环境下虚假信息的传播与治理研究”（项目批准号：20XCA004）的阶段性成果

作者(Author): 闫文捷,刘于思,周睿鸣

DOI: 10.16602/j.gjms.20220032

参考文献(References)：

• 卢卡斯·格雷夫斯(2022):《什么在决定真相：政治事实查验在美国新闻业的兴起》(周睿鸣、刘于思译),北京：中国人民大学出版社。
• 潘忠党(2021):走向有追求、有规范的新闻创新——新闻业的危机及认知的危机，《新闻记者》,第11期，8-20页。
• 周睿鸣(2021):元新闻话语、新闻认识论与中国新闻业转型，《南京社会科学》,第2期，108-117页。
• 周睿鸣、刘于思(2017):客观事实已经无效了吗?——“后真相”语境下事实查验的发展、效果与未来，《新闻记者》,第1期，36-44页。
• Allen,D.S.(2008).The trouble with transparency:The challenge of doing journalism ethics in a surveillance society.Journalism Studies,9(3),323-340.doi:10.1080/14616700801997224.
• Allen,J.,Arechar,A.A.,Pennycook,G.& Rand,D.G.(2021).Scaling up fact-checking using the wisdom of crowds.Science Advances,7(36),eabf4393.doi:10.1126/sciadv.abf4393.
• Amazeen,M.A.,Vargo,C.J.& Hopp,T.(2019).Reinforcing attitudes in a gatewatching news era:Individual-level antecedents to sharing fact-checks on social media.Communication Monographs,86(1),112-132.doi:10.1080/03637751.2018.1521984.
• Anderson,J.A.& Baym,G.(2004).Philosophies and philosophic issues in communication,1995-2004.Journal of Communication,54(4):589-615.doi:10.1111/j.1460-2466.2004.tb02647.x.
• Boczkowski,P.J.(2009).Rethinking hard and soft news production:From common ground to divergent paths.Journal of Communication,59(1),98-116.doi:10.1111/j.1460-2466.2008.01406.x.
• Brandtzaeg,P.B.,Lüders,M.,Spangenberg,J.,Rath-Wiggins,L.& F?lstad,A.(2016).Emerging journalistic verification practices concerning social media.Journalism Practice,10(3),323-342.doi:10.1080/17512786.2015.1020331.
• Carlson,M.(2016).Metajournalistic discourse and the meanings of journalism:Definitional control,boundary work,and legitimation.Communication Theory,26(4),349-368.doi:10.1111/comt.12088.
• Carlson,M.& Lewis,S.C.(2019).Boundary work.In Wahl-Jorgensen,K.& Hanitzsch,T.(Eds.),The handbook of journalism studies (2nd ed.,pp.123-135).New York:Routledge.
• Chalaby,J.K.(1996).Journalism as an Anglo-American invention:A comparison of the development of french and Anglo-American journalism,1830s-1920s.European Journal of Communication,11(3):303-326.doi:10.1177/0267323196011003002.
• Chen,Q.,Zhang,Y.Y.,Evans,R.& Min,C.(2021).Why do citizens share COVID-19 fact-checks posted by Chinese government social media accounts?The elaboration likelihood model.International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health,18(19),10058.doi:10.3390/ijerph181910058.
• Christie,B.(2022).Covid-19:Fact check—how many patients in hospital are unvaccinated?British Medical Journal,376,o5.doi:10.1136/bmj.o5.
• Coddington,M.,Molyneux,L.& Lawrence,R.G.(2014).Fact checking the campaign:How political reporters use Twitter to set the record straight (or not).The International Journal of Press/Politics,19(4),391-409.doi:10.1177/1940161214540942.
• Da,Z.& Huang,X.(2020).Harnessing the wisdom of crowds.Management Science,66(5),1847-1867.doi:10.1287/mnsc.2019.3294.
• Engesser,S.& Humprecht,E.(2015).Frequency or skillfulness:How professional news media use Twitter in five Western countries.Journalism Studies,16(4),513-529.doi:10.1080/1461670X.2014.939849.
• Epstein,Z.,Pennycook,G.& Rand,D.(2020).Will the crowd game the algorithm?:Using layperson judgments to combat misinformation on social media by downranking distrusted sources.In Proceedings of the 2020 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (pp.1-11).Honolulu,HI,USA:ACM.doi:10.1145/3313831.3376232.
• Ettema,J.S.& Glasser,T.L.(1998).Custodians of conscience.New York:Columbia University Press.
• Flamini,D.(July 3,2019).Most Republicans don't trust fact-checkers,and most Americans don't trust the media.Retrieved from https://www.poynter.org/ifcn/2019/most-republicans-dont-trust-fact-checkers-and-most-americans-dont-trust-the-media/.
• Gieryn,T.F.(1983).Boundary-work and the demarcation of science from non-science:Strains and interests in professional ideologies of scientists.American Sociological Review,48(6),781-795.doi:10.2307/2095325.
• Graves,L.(2016).Deciding what's true:The fact-checking movement in American journalism.New York:Columbia University Press.
• Graves,L.,Nyhan,B.& Reifler,J.(2016).Understanding innovations in journalistic practice:A field experiment examining motivations for fact-checking.Journal of Communication,66(1),102-138.doi:10.1111/jcom.12198.
• Hassan,N.,Yousuf,M.,Haque,M.,Rivas,J.A.S.& Islam,K.(2019).Examining the roles of automation,crowds and professionals towards sustainable fact-checking.In Companion Proceedings of the 2019 World Wide Web Conference (pp.1001-1006).San Francisco,CA,USA:ACM.doi:10.1145/3308560.3316734.
• Hermida,A.(2011).Mechanisms of participation:How audience options shape the conversation.In Singer,J.B.,Hermida,A.,Domingo,D.,Heinonen,A.,Paulussen,S.,Quandt,T.,Reich,Z.& Vujnovic,M.(Eds.),Participatory Journalism:Guarding Open Gates at Online Newspapers (pp.13-33).Malden:Wiley-Blackwell.
• Hocking,W.E.(1947).Freedom of the Press:A Framework of Principle.Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
• Humprecht,E.(2020).How do they debunk “fake news”?A cross-national comparison of transparency in fact checks.Digital Journalism,8(3),310-327.doi:10.1080/21670811.2019.1691031.
• Jamieson,K.H.& Waldman,P.(2003).The press effect:Politicians,journalists and the stories that shape the political world.New York:Oxford University Press.
• Karlsson,M.(2010).Rituals of transparency:Evaluating online news outlets' uses of transparency rituals in the United States,United Kingdom and Sweden.Journalism Studies,11(4),535-545.doi:10.1080/14616701003638400.
• Kovach,B.& Rosenstiel,T.(2001).The elements of journalism:What newspeople should know and the public should expect.New York:Three Rivers Press.
• Lawrence,R.G.& Schafer,M.L.(2012).Debunking sarah palin:Mainstream news coverage of ‘death panels’.Journalism,13(6),766-782.doi:10.1177/1464884911431389.
• Lawrence,R.G.,Radcliffe,D.& Schmidt,T.R.(2018).Practicing engagement:Participatory journalism in the Web 2.0 era.Journalism Practice,12(10),1220-1240.doi:17512786.2017.1391712.
• Lewis,S.C.(2012).The tension between professional control and open participation:Journalism and its boundaries.Information,Communication & Society,15(6),836-866.doi:10.1080/1369118X.2012.674150.
• Lewis,S.C.,Holton,A.E.& Coddington,M.(2014).Reciprocal journalism:A concept of mutual exchange between journalists and audiences.Journalism Practice,8(2),229-241.doi:10.1080/17512786.2013.859840.
• Lyons,B.,Mérola,V.,Reifler,J.& Stoeckel,F.(2020).How politics shape views toward fact-checking:Evidence from six European countries.The International Journal of Press/Politics,25(3),469-492.doi:10.1177/1940161220921732.
• Mahase,E.(2020).Covid-19:Was the decision to delay the UK's lockdown over fears of “behavioural fatigue” based on evidence?British Medical Journal,370,m3166.doi:10.1136/bmj.m3166.
• Michaels,D.& Monforton,C.(2005).Manufacturing uncertainty:Contested science and the protection of the public's health and environment.American Journal of Public Health,95(S1),S39-S48.doi:10.2105/AJPH.2004.043059.
• Misztal,B.A.(1995).Trust in modern societies:The search for the bases of social order.Cambridge:Polity Press.
• Newton,L.H.,Hodges,L.& Keith,S.(2004).Accountability in the professions:Accountability in journalism.Journal of Mass Media Ethics,19(3-4),166-190.doi:10.1080/08900523.2004.9679687.
• Nieminen,S.& Sankari,V.(2021).Checking PolitiFact's fact-checks.Journalism Studies,22(3),358-378.doi:10.1080/1461670X.2021.1873818.
• Nordenstreng,K.(1998).Hutchins goes global.Communication Law and Policy,3(3),419-438.doi:10.1080/10811689809368659.
• Nyhan,B.& Reifler,J.(2015).The effect of fact-checking on elites:A field experiment on U.S.state legislators.American Journal of Political Science,59(3),628-640.doi:10.1111/ajps.12162.
• Park,R.E.(1940).News as a form of knowledge:A chapter in the sociology of knowledge.American Journal of Sociology,45(5),670-686.
• Pennycook,G.,Bear,A.,Collins,E.T.& Rand,D.G.(2020).The implied truth effect:Attaching warnings to a subset of fake news headlines increases perceived accuracy of headlines without warnings.Management Science,66(11),4944-4957.doi:10.1287/mnsc.2019.3478.
• Phillips,A.(2010).Transparency and the new ethics of journalism.Journalism Practice,4(3),373-382.doi:10.1080/17512781003642972.
• Pingree,R.J.2011.Effects of unresolved factual disputes in the news on epistemic political efficacy.Journal of Communication 61(1):22-47.doi:10.1111/j.1460-2466.2010.01525.x
• Poynter.(May 28,2022).The coronavirusfacts/datoscoronavirus alliance database.Retrieved from https://www.poynter.org/ifcn-covid-19-misinformation/.
• Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism & Oxford Internet Institute.(April 7,2020).Types,sources,and claims of COVID-19 misinformation.Retrieved from https://reutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac.uk/types-sources-and-claims-covid-19-misinformation.
• Revers,M.(2014).The twitterization of news making:Transparency and journalistic professionalism.Journal of Communication,64(5),806-826.doi:10.1111/jcom.12111.
• Robinson,S.(2010).Traditionalists vs.Convergers:Textual privilege,boundary work,and the journalist—audience relationship in the commenting policies of online news sites.Convergence,16(1),125-143.doi:10.1177/1354856509347719.
• Schudson,M.(2001).The objectivity norm in American journalism.Journalism,2(2),149-170.doi:10.1177/146488490100200201.
• Singer,J.B.(2007).Contested autonomy:Professional and popular claims on journalistic norms.Journalism Studies,8(1),79-95.doi:10.1080/14616700601056866.
• Singer,J.B.(2010).Norms and the network:Journalistic ethics in a shared media space.In Meyers,C.(Eds.),Journalism Ethics:A Philosophical Approach,117-129.New York:Oxford University Press.
• Singer,J.B.,Hermida,A.,Domingo,D.,Heinonen,A.,Paulussen,S.,Quandt,T.,Reich,Z.& Vujnovic,M.(2011).Participatory journalism:Guarding open gates at online newspapers.Malden:Wiley-Blackwell.
• Singer,J.B.(2021).Border patrol:The rise and role of fact-checkers and their challenge to journalists' normative boundaries.Journalism,22(8),1929-1946.doi:10.1177/1464884920933137.
• Streckfuss,R.(1990).Objectivity in journalism:A search and a reassessment.Journalism Quarterly,67(4),973-983.
• Surowiecki,J.(2005).The wisdom of crowds.New York:Anchor.
• Tuchman,G.(1978).Making news:A study in the construction of reality.New York:Free Press.
• Usher,N.(2020).News cartography and epistemic authority in the era of big data:Journalists as map-makers,map-users,and map-subjects.New Media & Society,22(2),247-263.doi:10.1177/1461444819856909.
• Wahl-Jorgensen,K.(2015).Resisting epistemologies of user-generated content?In Carlson,M.& Lewis,S.C.(Eds.),Boundaries of Journalism:Professionalism,Practices and Participation (pp.169-185).London:Routledge.
• Walker,M.& Gottfried,J.(July 9,2019).Republicans far more likely than Democrats to say fact-checkers tend to favor one side.Retrieved from https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/06/27/republicans-far-more-likely-than-democrats-to-say-fact-checkers-tend-to-favor-one-side/
• Wien,C.(2005).Defining objectivity within journalism:An overview.Nordicom Review,26(2),3-15.doi:10.1515/nor-2017-0255
• ① 有关Birdwatch平台的介绍来自Twitter官网：https://blog.twitter.com/en_us/topics/product/2021/introducing-birdwatch-a-community-based-approach-to-misin formation.