粉丝研究流变:主体性、理论问题与研究路径Review of Fandom Studies: Subjectivity, Theory and Research Pathway
尹一伊
摘要(Abstract):
随着数字技术与文化产业的发展,粉丝、亚文化与流行文化正在成为业界与文化研究中的关键词。本文对20世纪80年代以来的国内外粉丝研究进行综述,归纳作为学术领域的粉丝研究的特征,并指出粉丝主体性在粉丝研究中的必要性。本文认为,中国的本土粉丝研究现状面临着"粉丝缺席"、研究对象本质化的倾向与问题。通过对粉丝研究领域的梳理,本文希望为本土粉丝研究与公众讨论提供理论视角与研究框架上的启发。
关键词(KeyWords): 粉丝研究;粉丝文化;粉丝实践;数字媒体;社群规则
基金项目(Foundation):
作者(Author): 尹一伊
DOI: 10.16602/j.gmj.20200004
参考文献(References):
- 本尼迪克特·安德森(2005):《想象的共同体》(吴叡人译),上海:上海人民出版社。(原书 Anderson,B.[1991].Imagined communities.New York:Verso.)
- 储卉娟(2019):《说书人与梦工厂:技术、法律与网络文学生产》,北京:社会科学文献出版社。
- 胡岑岑(2019年9月21日):周杰伦超话登顶的背后——粉丝组织跨时代的变与不变,获取自http://zhishifenzi.com/depth/depth/6949.html。
- 刘阳子|门柱(2019年7月21日):饭圈与游戏化,获取自https://weibointl.api.weibo.cn/share/125533853.html?weibo_id=4396625474203155。
- 邵燕君 (2016):再见“美丰仪”与“腐女文化”的逆袭——一场静悄悄发生的性别革命,《南方文坛》,第 2期,55-58页。
- 杨玲(2012):《 转型时代的娱乐狂欢:超女粉丝与大众文化消费》,北京:中国社会科学出版社。
- 赵皓阳(2018年11月29日):粉圈心理研究:追星是女性的“母爱”无法寄托,就把爱豆当孩子养,获取自http://www.sohu.com/a/278633251_100166604。
- 郑雪梅(2010):大众传媒文化之网络文化现象解析——网络耽美文学流行现象中的社会心态,《文学界》,第 7期,203-204页。
- 郑熙青(2015):Alpha Beta Omega的性别政治——网络粉丝耽美写作中女性的自我探索与反思,《中国图书评论》,第11期,18-27页。
- 周潞鹭(2014):中國內地粉絲,香港電視明星與跨境文化消費 ,香港中文大学博士论文。
- Abercrombie,N.& Longhurst,B.(1998).Audiences:A sociological theory of performance and imagination.London,United Kingdom:Sage.
- Andrejevic,M.(2011).The work that affective economics does.Cultural Studies,25(4-5):604-620.doi:10.1080/09502386.2011.600551
- Azuma,H.(2001).Otaku:Japan's database animals.MN:University of Minnesota Press.
- Bacon-Smith,C.(1992).Enterprising women:Television fandom and the creation of popular myth.PA:University of Pennsylvania Press.
- Couldry,N.& Hepp,A.(2017).The mediated construction of reality.MA:Polity Press.
- De Certeau,M.(1984).The practice of everyday life.CA:University of California Press.
- Elliott,A.(1999).The mourning of john Lennon.CA:University of California Press.
- Fiske,J.(1989).Reading the popular.NY:Routledge.
- Fung,A.(2009).Faye and the fandom of a Chinese Diva.Popular Communication,7(4),252-266.doi:10.1080/15405700903177552
- Fung,A.(2013).Pleasant goat and grey wolf:Creative industry,market and the state-animated modernity in China.International Journal of Cultural and Creative Industries,1(1),54-65.doi:10.1177/0163443719863353
- Fung,A.Y.(2019).Fandomization of online video or television in China.Media,Culture & Society,41(7),995-1010.doi:10.1177/0163443719863353
- Gray,J.,Sandvoss,C.& Harrington,C.L.(2007).Introduction:Why study fans?.In Gray,J.,Sandvoss,C.& Harrington,C.L.(Eds.),Fandom:Identities and Communities in a Mediated World (pp.1-18).NY:New York University Press.
- Grossberg,L.(1992).Is there a fan in the house?The affective sensibility of fandom.In Lewis,L.A.(Ed.),The Adoring Audience:Fan Culture and Popular Media (pp.50-65).New York:Routledge.
- Hall,S.(1977).Encoding/decoding.In During,S.(Ed.),The Cultural Studies Reader (pp.90-105).London,United Kingdom:Routledge.
- Harrington,C.L.& Bielby,D.D.(1995).Soap fans:Pursuing pleasure and making meaning in everyday life.PA:Temple University Press.
- Harris,C.(1998).A sociology of television fandom.In Harris,C.& Alexander A.(Eds.),Theorizing Fandom:Fans,Subculture and Identity (pp.41-54).Cresskill,United Kingdom:Hampton Press.
- Hills,M.(2002).Fan cultures.NY:Routledge.
- Hills,M.(2014).Returning to “becoming-a-fan” stories:Theorising transformational objects and the emergence/extension of fandom.In Duits,L.,Zwaan,K.& Reijnders,S.(Eds.),The Ashgate Research Companion to Fan Cultures (pp.9-22).Farnham,United Kingdom:Ashgate.
- Hills,M.(2016).From para-social to multisocial interaction.In Marshall,P.D.& Redmond,S.(Eds.),A Companion to Celebrity (pp.463-482).Oxford,United Kingdom:John Wiley & Sons.
- Illouz,E.(2007).Cold intimacies:The making of emotional capitalism.MA:Polity Press.
- Illouz,E.(2017).Introduction:Emodities or the making of motional commodities.In Illouz E.(Eds.),Emotions as Commodities:Capitalism,Consumption and Authenticity (pp.1-28).NY:Routledge.
- Ito,M.,Okabe,D.& Tsuji,I.(2012).Fandom unbound:Otaku culture in a connected world.CT:Yale University Press.
- Jancovich,M.(2002).Cult fictions:Cult movies,subcultural capital and the production of cultural distinctions.Cultural Studies,16(2),306-322.doi:10.1080/09502380110107607
- Jenkins,H.(1988).Star Trek rerun,reread,rewritten:Fan writing as textual poaching.Critical Studies in Mass Communication,5(2),85-107.doi:10.1080/15295038809366691
- Jenkins,H.(1992).Textual poachers:Television fans and participatory culture.NY:Routledge.
- Jenkins,H.(2006a).Convergence culture:Where old and new media collide.NY:New York University Press.
- Jenkins,H.(2006b).Fans,bloggers,and gamers:Exploring participatory culture.NY:New York University Press.
- Liu,H.L.(2019).From cyber-nationalism to fandom nationalism:The case of Diba expedition in China.NY:Routledge.
- Redmond,S.(2014).Celebrity and the media.London:Palgrave Macmillan.
- Sandvoss,C.(2005).Fans:The mirror of consumption.MA:Polity Press.
- Stacey,J.(1994).Star gazing:Hollywood cinema and female spectatorship.London,United Kingdom:Routledge.
- Thornton,S.(1995).Club cultures:Music,media and subcultural capital.MA:Polity Press.
- Van Krieken,R.(2012).Celebrity society.London,United Kingdom:Routledge.
- Williams,R.(1961).The long revolution:An analysis of the democratic,industrial,and cultural changes transforming our society.NY:Columbia University Press.
- Winnicott,D.W.(2005).Playing and reality.London:Routledge.
- Yang,L.(2009).All for love:The Corn fandom,prosumers,and the Chinese way of creating a superstar.International Journal of Cultural Studies,12(5),527-543.doi:10.1177/1367877909337863
- Yin,Y.& Fung,A.(2017).Youth online cultural participation and Bilibili:An alternative form of digital democracy?.In Luppicini,R.& Baarda R.(Eds.),Digital Media Integration for Participatory Democracy (pp.130-154).PA:IGI Global.
- Yin,Y.& Xie,Z.X.(2018).The bounded embodiment of fandom in China:Recovering shifting media experiences and fan participation through an oral history of Animation-Comics-Games lovers.International Journal of Communication,12,3317-3334.
- Zhang,W.Y.(2015).The internet and new social formation in China:Fandom publics in the making.NY:Routledge.
- Zheng,X.Q.(2016).Borderless fandom and contemporary popular cultural scene in Chinese Cyberspace.PhD dissertation,University of Washington,Washington.
- ① 粉丝的“病理化”指将粉丝文化归因为假定的心理症候。此处沿用Joli Jesen (1992),“Fandom as Pathology”一文中对粉丝病态及病理化的定义。
- ② 本质化(essentialism),指将主体理解为固定存在的、一成不变的本质(essence)或实体。